NCAA Sports

Some colleges are ‘using pandemic as an excuse’ to eliminate athletics programs


CLOSE

SportsPulse: The NCAA tournaments have been postponed and, as Dan Wolken states, it was a decision that had to be made. USA TODAY

Sports programs are starting to fall like dominoes as college athletics departments face unprecedented financial challenges during the coronavirus pandemic.

The baseball programs at Bowling Green State University in Ohio and at Furman University in South Carolina, which were eliminated this week, are the latest casualties among more than a dozen Division I athletics teams to have been cut nationwide since last month.

B. David Ridpath, associate professor of sports business at Ohio University and interim president of the Drake Group, a national nonprofit advocacy organization, said he believes some college leaders are conveniently using COVID-19’s economic impact as a reason for trimming sports, instead of implementing other cost-cutting measures.

“There’s a lot of fat that can be cut before sports being dropped,” said Ridpath, a former wrestling coach at Ohio University who previously served as an athletics administrator at Weber State University.

“I think dropping sports is basically a knee-jerk reaction and many of the schools are using the pandemic as an excuse for something they already wanted to do. There may come a time where dropping a sport is a viable solution, but it should be the last one and based on many different things.”

 David Ridpath

David Ridpath  (Photo: Ohio University )

All but three of the 15 programs that have reportedly been eliminated at Division I colleges including Cincinnati, Old Dominion, Akron, Central Michigan, East Carolina and Florida International are men’s sports, which are often the first to be trimmed as schools, especially those with football programs, strive to comply with Title IX, the federal law requiring gender equity for participation and scholarship opportunities.

“Dropping a sport and saying you are doing it for gender equity I think is an excuse,” Ridpath said.

READ: Rutgers parent sues for tuition refund after COVID-19 closed campuses

“People don’t realize spending on football and men’s basketball has quadrupled since Title IX enforcement. There are opportunities to actually keep costs (for revenue sports) down. It’s not Title IX’s fault that male salaries and spending has gone up. We can reduce costs in football and help save a wrestling program (such as that which Old Dominion eliminated). We just haven’t done that.”

$3.6 billion in tuition

Ridpath said he believes a college’s decision to eliminate nonrevenue sports, such as baseball, which spreads a total of 11.7 scholarships across 35-player rosters, could “backfire and hurt the overall university enrollment-wise” as schools lose tuition-paying students.

According to the latest data, a record 499,217 student-athletes, many of which pay tuition, participated in NCAA championship sports across all three divisions during the 2018-19 academic year. 

The Intercollegiate Coach Association Coalition reported 141,483 of those athletes participated in Division I nonrevenue sports, generating $3.6 billion in tuition and fees for their universities, an amount the coalition says is nearly equal to the total expense of providing playing opportunities for those students.

“Dropping these sports, you’re likely losing bodies, and that counts against your overall enrollment,” Ridpath said. “Enrollment is going down nationwide and (colleges cutting sports) are not really looking at the whole picture here.”

Jeremy Rebetje, Bridgewater Raritan High SchoolNicholas Rebetje, Bridgewater Raritan High SchoolMadison Moskal, South Amboy High SchoolMikaela McLurkin, Montclair State University. Hometown: WoodbridgeStephen Karczewski, Spotswood High School. Hometown: HelmettaClaudia Torres, University of Notre Dame. Hometown: North BrunswickBrittany Rojas, Raritan Valley Community College. Hometown: South Bound BrookPaige Palazzi, Savannah College of Art and Design. Hometown: Whitehouse StationKaitlyn Perdigao, David Brearley High School. Hometown: KenilworthBrandie Tartza, Marquette University Law School. Hometown: SayrevilleMickey Wasko, Bridgewater-Raritan High SchoolDana Quinn, Columbia University Law School. Hometown: SayrevilleAlyssa Moody of Pittstown,  North Hunterdon High SchoolFabian Thomas Ardila, Bridgewater-Raritan High SchoolMallory Alyssa Golden of Flemington,   Hunterdon Central Regional High SchoolNikole Arias, Colonia High SchoolAlexis Robinson, South Plainfield High SchoolAndrew C. Ramos, North Brunswick Township High SchoolAshley Levitt, North Brunswick High SchoolCharlie Vizthum, North Brunswick High SchoolDerek Rossman, North Brunswick High SchoolNatalia Adela Jimenez, Manville High SchoolJohn Slover, Monroe Township High SchoolNicholas P. Ramos, Montclair State UniversityJamine Stevens, New Brunswick High SchoolDominic Ingram, Jr., New Brunswick High SchoolJoseph Sidotti, North Brunswick Township High SchoolSydnee Hopson, North Brunswick Township High SchoolElizabeth LaVielle of North Brunswick, Rutgers UniversityStephanie DiMinno, North Brunswick Township High SchoolSean Tarnowski of Keasby, John F. Kennedy Memorial High SchoolDylan Tarnowski of Keasby, John F. Kennedy Memorial High SchoolHolly Mairs, North Brunswick High SchoolAndrew LaVielle, North Brunswick High SchoolDavid Polgardi of Jamesburg, Monroe Township High SchoolJhamie L. Allen of Somerset, Franklin High SchoolDevin Kuebler of Monroe, Middlesex Vocational and Technical School, East Brunswick campusPaul Kuchler, North Brunswick Township High SchoolJenna Bottiglieri of Milltown, Rowan UniversityDanielle Errico, Rutgers UniversityKaralyn Hoover of East Brunswick, Monmouth University  Summa Cum LaudeMarcus Feggins, South Brunswick High SchoolLynne Gordon of North Brunswick, Middlesex County CollegeMichelle Evelyn Hansen of Jamesburg, Kean University  Summa Cum Laude, BA Early Childhood Education/Teacher of Students with DisabilitiesLauren A. Steinkopf of Bedminster, Bernards High SchoolAshley Montuoro, Edison High SchoolCassandra Cavalluzzi, Monroe Township High SchoolAlyssa Zeeb, Piscataway High SchoolKaitlyn Zeeb, Piscataway High SchoolMatthew Tinitigan of Jamesburg, Monroe Township High SchoolBri Edris, Kaleigh Jess and Riley Sheeley Somerville High SchoolJada Fletcher of Branchburg, Rider University,Lauren Stavac, Delaware Valley Regional High SchoolRachel Schoss, Scotch Plains-Fanwood High SchoolSteven Campbell, Rahway High SchoolRyan Kappes, North Brunswick High SchoolDaniel Simpson Jr., North Brunswick High SchoolJessica Hendershot, North Warren High SchoolAnton Zambell, Scotch Plains-Fanwood High SchoolGrace de Araujo, Edison High SchoolElizabeth Klimek, J.F. Kennedy High SchoolJonathan Benowitz, East Brunswick High SchoolSarah Wooby, Kean University. Hometown: Neshanic StationKathryn Klimek, J.F. Kennedy High SchoolChristopher Eckel, Piscataway High SchoolKayla Tango, Edison High SchoolTroy Henderson Jr., North Plainfield High SchoolCJ Talerico, St. Joseph High School (Metuchen)Kylie Aldrich, Somerville High School and Raritan Valley Community CollegeMarie L. Bosslett, J.P. Stevens High SchoolJennifer Palladino, Edison High SchoolBrandon Villalba, Spotswood High SchoolKenneth E. Bradley, North Plainfield High SchoolRowan Thomas-Tarighi, Mother Seton High School. Hometown: EdisonDominic Petrocci, St. Joseph High School (Metuchen). Hometown: MilltownAlexa Noon, East Brunswick Tech. Hometown: South AmboyKatelyn Barbosa, Sayreville High SchoolEthan Vargas, Edison High SchoolAdrian Dilascio, Monroe High SchoolRebecca Abbatemarco, Edison High SchoolMadison Goode, Edison High SchoolRiya Patel, Edison High SchoolElton D. Byrd, Edison High SchoolJoseph Della Sala, J.F. Kennedy High SchoolF. Hunter Trstensky, Delaware Valley High SchoolGavin Stellpflug, Somerville High SchoolJosh Gold, Bridgewater-Raritan High SchoolSydney Tran, Hillsborough High SchoolGabrielle Dellaglio, Spotswood High SchoolJacqueline Diaz, Bound Brook High SchoolJake Galati, Middlesex High SchoolRayonnah Davis, New Brunswick High SchoolJoy Baptista, Monroe High SchoolRiley Larkin Fitz, Delaware Valley High SchoolKayla Dekovics, Spotswood High SchoolErin Kowalski, South River High SchoolMichael Waters, Hunterdon Central High SchoolCaroline Waters, Hunterdon Central High SchoolLuca Moscetti, Bridgewater-Raritan High SchoolNikolas Leon, J.F. Kennedy High SchoolAbby Gwizdz, Hunterdon Central High SchoolAryana Perez, Woodbridge High SchoolBrian Koenig, East Brunswick Tech. Hometown: EdisonKayla Soto, Colonia High SchoolKatelyn Clemens, J.P. Stevens High SchoolJakob Cherry, Metuchen High SchoolJake Rothstein, St. Joseph High School (Metuchen). Hometown: WoodbridgeScott Oshman, South Amboy High SchoolEmily Stetson, Ohio State University. Hometown: East BrunswickAnthony Pensak, Rutgers University. Hometown: EdisonAaron Dixon, Manville High SchoolMarisa Campione, Hofstra University. Hometown: EdisonJuliette Warren, North Hunterdon High SchoolEric Bryant Jr., Somerville High SchoolEllie Hirst, Delaware Valley High SchoolShea Cinquemani, Delaware Valley High SchoolKylee Fuerstenberger, Delaware Valley High SchoolKaleigh Higgins, Delaware Valley High SchoolPatrick Thomas Lawson, Somerville High SchoolJeffrey Campbell, Delaware Valley High SchoolGriffin Ryan McDougall, North Hunterdon High SchoolMadelyn Gaffney, Delaware Valley High SchoolJo-Vanni Smith, Sayreville High SchoolBrandon Schuetz, Delaware Valley High ScholAshley Mullins, Hillsborough High SchoolDante Brantley, Perth Amboy High SchoolZachary Wilt, Delaware Valley High SchoolAndrew Jonathan Brucato, Monroe High SchoolCaitlyn Soong, Hunterdon Central High SchoolCaroline Wendland, Bridgewater-Raritan High SchoolFaith Ciesla, Seton Hall University and Scott Ciesla, Felician University. Hometown: Middlesex.Maddy Melchione, Hunterdon Central High SchoolAustyn Urbanski, St. Thomas Aquinas High School. Hometown: EdisonSamira Marie Bailey, Phillipsburg High SchoolMark Schulz, Hunterdon Central High SchoolEmerson Harper, Spotswood High SchoolCaitlin Whalen, Farleigh Dickinson University. Hometown: AnnandaleDaniel Magda, North Hunterdon High SchoolZachary Shiffman, Somerville High SchoolHaley Calderaro, Franklin High SchoolNicole Zebrowski, J.P. Stevens High SchoolElizabeth Ruckdeschel, Monroe High SchoolAlyssa Bell, East Brunswick Tech. Hometown: Old BridgeNathaniel Janes, Our Lady of Victories (Sayreville). Hometown: East BrunswickAustin Cravo, East Brunswick High SchoolJeremy Ryan, Perth Amboy Tech. Hometown: HelmettaErica Rubino, Monroe High SchoolKayla Rose Shockley, Edison High SchoolKyle Siegel, Monroe High SchoolFaith Gregory, Sayreville High SchoolJulia Irizarry, Colonia High SchoolTori Pinto, South River High SchoolSean Gumpper, East Brunswick High SchoolRyan Martin, Woodbridge High SchoolMichael Magielnicki, Sayreville High SchoolMelanie Oliva, Colonia High SchoolLeanna Pede, East Brunswick Tech. Hometown: MonroeLaura Adams, South Hunterdon High SchoolJoshua Podmayersky, Woodbridge High SchoolEmily Cardinale, East Brunswick Tech. Hometown: SayrevilleGauri Prabhakar, East Brunswick High SchoolLucas Teeple, J.F. Kennedy High SchoolThomas Perpente, Spotswood High SchoolScott Rubin, Highland Park High SchoolKirk Olsen, Woodbridge High SchoolSarah Upwood, Voorhees High SchoolSahra Reyes, Montclair State University. Hometown: RaritanSean Reilly, Somerville High SchoolMatthew Cianfaro, Somerville High SchoolCassie Quinn, Hunterdon Central High SchoolKatie Quinn, Hunterdon Central High SchoolTaaje Welcome, New Brunswick High SchoolTyambra Moore, New Brunswick High SchoolEliza David, Immaculata High School. Hometown: SayrevillePatrick Dwyer, Immaculata High School. Hometown: SomervilleRyan Corcoran, Somerville High SchoolThomas Sviderskis-Carroll, Immaculata High School. Hometown: MiddlesexJenna Potts, Somerville High SchoolChristopher Finlan, High Point University. Hometown: BranchburgPelton Esannason Jr., Immaculata High School. Hometown: SomervilleKyle Murray, Somerville High SchoolJohnFrank LaCorte, Freehold High SchoolChristine Arcoleo, University of Notre Dame. Hometown: BridgewaterBri Edris, Somerville High SchoolShelby Pyatt, Delaware Valley High SchoolTevin Ighalo, Somerville High SchoolZach Pryor, Delaware Valley High SchoolHolly Leary, J.P. Stevens High SchoolMark Feniello, South River High SchoolVictoria Talharim, South River High SchoolNicholas Nielson, Colonia High SchoolAshley Shourt, Edison High SchoolJack Calabrese, Edison High SchoolKyle O’Hara, Rutgers Prep. Hometown: BridgewaterChristopher Sommer, Edison High SchoolArthur N. Diem III, St. Joseph High School (Metuchen). Hometown: MilltownMatthew Valencia, Immaculata High School. Hometown: North PlainfieldAndrea Maris, J.P. Stevens High SchoolAlexandra Maris, Rutgers University. Hometown: EdisonJustin Raymond Hunte, Union County TEAMS Charter School (Plainfield)Anthony Zimmerman, Sayreville High SchoolKaitlyn Schoendorf, North Hunterdon High SchoolMichael Medwick, Woodbridge High SchoolJason Weber, Colonia High SchoolSteven Rodriguez, South River High SchoolJack Bostjancic, St. Joseph High School (Metuchen)Jared Copeland, Piscataway High SchoolSelena Thorne, Rutgers University. Hometown: SomersetAlyson Kratchman, Monroe High SchoolNina Danner, Seton Hall University. Hometown: Green Brook

Replay

Autoplay

Show Thumbnails

Show Captions

Real economic crisis

Athletics departments whose schools are members of Power 5 conferences appear, for the most part, better equipped than others to weather the economic fallout of the pandemic, as gate receipts and revenue sharing from football and men’s basketball have helped subsidize their non-revenue sports. 

None of the Power 5 schools to date has eliminated a sports program.

According to a Lead1 Association and Teamworks national survey of 100 Football Bowl Subdivision athletics directors, 41 percent of administrators from Power 5 schools surveyed believe their departments have the financial reserve to navigate the coronavirus pandemic, while 26 percent of administrators from mid-majors who responded believe their departments are monetarily equipped to navigate the fiscal crisis.  

The stability of those athletics departments, many of which rely on institutional support, will be challenged more than ever as higher education, which shifted from in-person instruction to online learning, faces an uncertain future regarding the return of students to school and the playing of games on campus.

READ: Major public college football programs could lose billions in revenue if no season is played

Of the more than two dozen four-year colleges and universities in New Jersey, Rutgers is the lone member of a Power 5 conference.

The school’s New Brunswick campus rests in the heart of a state that ranks second nationally in COVID-19 positive cases and coronavirus-related deaths.

Epitomizing the very real economic crises colleges face, Rutgers anticipates a university shortfall of $200 million in its budgeted revenues over the remainder of the fiscal year, which concludes at the end of next month.

Rutgers president Robert Barchi said the school “will not close this gap on the backs of our students and their families,” calling on the board of governors to freeze undergraduate tuition and fees at current levels.

Barchi said the state university and all of higher education is confronting “perhaps the greatest academic and operational challenge in its history.”

Rutgers has not trimmed its athletics programs since eliminating six sports – men’s heavyweight crew, men’s lightweight crew, men’s fencing, men’s swimming and diving, men’s tennis and women’s fencing – 14 years ago.

Asked if the state university, which offers 22 programs, plans on cutting sports as a result of the pandemic’s economic impact, a spokesperson for Rutgers athletics declined comment.

About 40 miles south, Marilyn McNeil, the athletics director at Monmouth University, a member of the Football Championship Subdivision, whose gridiron squad is scheduled to open the 2020 campaign at Rutgers, wants to preserve her department’s 21 sports offerings.

Monmouth University Athletics Director Marilyn McNeil

Monmouth University Athletics Director Marilyn McNeil (Photo: James J.Connolly)

“I am devastated when I see schools cut sports,” McNeil previously told USA TODAY NETWORK New Jersey. “I really hope nobody uses this (health crisis) as a reason to do that.

“I understand sometimes you have to make hard decisions. But as I’ve always said, maybe you’ve got to divide the pie up a little differently. We’ll all have to look at what’s truly important.”  

Other cost-cutting measures

A reduction in subsidies from student fees and institutional support due to declining enrollment, anticipated cuts in federal and state funding to public universities, a decrease in alumni giving amid record national unemployment rates, a reduction from $600 million to $225 million in NCAA revenue distribution following the cancellation of the 2020 men’s basketball tournament, and the potential loss of television and ticket revenue from the upcoming football season are adversely impacting the finances of college athletics programs.

Ridpath said athletics departments should immediately consider introducing cost-cutting measures including reductions in personnel, reductions in operating and travel costs, salary cuts and freezes, as well as a moratorium on building new athletics-only facilities and upgrades to existing facilities.

Rutgers, to that end, has been proactive. Barchi announced last month that football coach Greg Schiano, men’s basketball coach Steve Pikiell, women’s basketball coach C. Vivian Stringer and athletics director Pat Hobbs will take a 10 percent reduction in salary through August. The entire leadership team of the state university’s athletics department will endure a 5 percent pay cut over the same time period. In addition, Barchi announced all plans for new capital construction projects will be stopped and all active projects will be reviewed.

Rutgers University football coach Greg Schiano will take a 10 percent salary cut over a four-month period.Buy Photo

Rutgers University football coach Greg Schiano will take a 10 percent salary cut over a four-month period. (Photo: Rich Schultz, Getty Images)

Profligate spending

“I have to give them at least credit here, but I won’t give them credit with what they have done up to now,” said Ridpath, adding he believes the Rutgers athletics department has long engaged in profligate spending. 

According to an NJ Advance Media report, the Rutgers athletics department shows a deficit of $445 million since 2003-04 and of $238 million since Barchi became the university’s president eight years ago.

Supporters of Rutgers athletics maintain the state university’s investment is the price of competing in the Big Ten, whose projected $65.2 million in revenue-sharing by the year 2027 will benefit the school in its quest to become financially self-sufficient.

“The Big Ten gave them a lifeline,” Ridpath said. “Because of that, I think they were fortunate. I think they can survive. I think without that, they would have been dead in the water with what they were doing financially. I’ve definitely been hard on Rutgers over the years, and certainly they put themselves in a pretty poor financial position.”

According to a USA TODAY analysis of college athletics spending, Rutgers spent $102.5 million on athletics during the 2017-18 academic year, ranking 36th nationally and 11th in the 14-team Big Ten Conference.

Comparatively, fellow league members Ohio State ($203.8 million) and Michigan ($183.4 million) ranked second and third, respectively, among colleges nationwide in 2017-18 athletic department spending.

‘It was a crass thing’

Ridpath said he believes a recent maneuver from commissioners of five mid-major conferences, which failed, was an attempt to undermine nonrevenue sports.

The Division I Council of the NCAA last month rejected the commissioners’ request for a years-long waiver to an NCAA bylaw that requires schools to sponsor a minimum of 16 sports programs to maintain their Division I status (colleges can still apply for independent waivers).

“I thought it was a crass thing for conferences to ask,” Ridpath said. “They were asking for temporary relief. Everyone knows once those sports are gone, they’re gone. They were looking for an easy way out instead of addressing the fat. The easy way out is let’s get rid of these sports and try to preserve the excess in football and men’s basketball. Thankfully, that (appeal) was turned down. It still doesn’t help if schools are above the minimum (with latitude to cut sports).”

Ron Mitchelson, the interim chancellor at East Carolina University, said his school’s decision to eliminate four sports – men’s and women’s tennis and men’s and women’s swimming and diving – resulted from a deliberate review and in-depth analysis of the athletics department’s budgets and programs.

“The current athletics budget was not sustainable pre-COVID-19 and the university was working closely with athletics to decrease the annual deficit over the next year,” he said in a statement. “With the pandemic, the deficit began to grow significantly where the impact was immediate and will affect future revenue and expenses for years to come. Ultimately, the reduction of sports aligns ECU with our American Athletic Conference peers and provides a roadmap to a more sustainable future for the University and athletics.”

In addition to eliminating four sports – the most any college has cut thus far – East Carolina trimmed athletics operations. The school reduced its sports budget by regionalizing scheduling and travel for select sports, eliminating several positions that are currently vacant, limiting summer school for student-athletes and suspending all professional development conferences for a minimum of one year.

The moves are expected to save the school an estimated $4.9 million.

Rutgers President Robert Barchi talks before Greg Schiano is introduced for his second tour as Rutgers head football coach on December 4, 2019 at the Hale Center on Rutgers campus in Piscataway, NJ.

Rutgers President Robert Barchi talks before Greg Schiano is introduced for his second tour as Rutgers head football coach on December 4, 2019 at the Hale Center on Rutgers campus in Piscataway, NJ. (Photo: Chris Pedota, NorthJersey.com-USA Today Network)

‘Playing a game we can’t win’

The Drake Group, whose mission is to defend academic integrity in higher education from the corrosive aspects of commercialized college sports, encourages a “students-first” approach during the pandemic.

The organization urges schools to retain all sports, maintain scholarship commitments and maintain operating costs for direct student-athlete services such as athletic training, insurance, medical expenses and academic support.

Ridpath said he believes college athletics departments and the leagues with which they are affiliated must become creative in devising ways to keep alive sports programs.

Ridpath praised the Mid-American Conference, of which Ohio University, where he teaches, is a member, for issuing a league-wide mandate prohibiting the conference’s home football teams from staying in hotels on the eve of games. Ridpath said he believed the measure will save his college’s athletics department approximately $60,000.

Old Dominion University has eliminated in wrestling program.

Old Dominion University has eliminated in wrestling program. (Photo: Courtesy of Katy Jones)

“I don’t think a school would have done that unilaterally,” Ridpath said. “Those are easy cuts, but you still don’t see presidents and athletics directors making those easy cuts. We have a lot of unnecessary (spending) at the Mid-American Conference level. We are playing a game we can’t win. We are not Ohio State, and we shouldn’t be.”

Rob Wilson, associate athletics director at Florida State University, which spent almost $96,000 on home-game hotel rooms in 2018, according to USA TODAY, defended the practice. He said such overnight stays eliminate distractions in a college town for upperclassmen, who are spread out across the city in private housing, including large apartment complexes that often have loud, late-night parties.

The Mid-American Conference introduced other cost-cutting measures this month, announcing it has eliminated several postseason conference tournaments and overhauled the postseason for men’s and women’s basketball.

Such moves will save thousands of dollars per institution, but some conference member schools are facing multi-million dollar budget deficits.

Akron Athletics Director Larry Williams said the university’s decision to cut three sports will save the school approximately $4.4 million, which accounts for 23 percent of the college’s financial support of the athletics department.

Bowling Green State University said in a release eliminating its baseball program will save the athletics department approximately $500,000 annually, helping to offset a $2 million budget deficit.

The elimination of Central Michigan’s men’s indoor and outdoor track and field programs will help the school recoup a projected $628,000 per year.

According to the Green Bay Press-Gazette, Wisconsin-Green Bay is indefinitely suspending its men’s and women’s tennis programs, saving the school $230,000 annually in operating costs and scholarships.

“We’re not seeing real leadership,” Ridpath said in reference to some of the schools that are eliminating sports. “Desperate times call for desperate measures.”

Those measures, he said, should not yet call for eliminating programs.

Email: gtufaro@gannettnj.com

Continue reading from the Source

Avatar
GameDay
Welcome to GameDay.Blog Powered by SportsBook-Live.com. Please register to our site, As more States become Available for Online Gambling, We will automatically upgrade your status from Subscriber to Player. Please note we are not affilliated in any way with ESPN, CBS Sports, Home depot or CitiBank GameDay Programs.
https://college.gameday.blog